COMPARE

Informed Decisions or Place Info: how the two forecasts compare

Informed Decisions and Place Info both publish population and dwelling forecasts for Australian communities, and are sometimes bought by the same organisations for similar purposes. They are different kinds of product.

Place Info's Place Forecast reflects back the assumptions of whoever is using it. It supplies a starting position, then hands the user the controls to change it, so local knowledge, and local expectations, go straight into the numbers.

Informed Decisions' National Forecasting Program is an independent assessment of the most likely future for a place, produced by a dedicated team of demographers on one consistent method for every part of Australia. It rests on three things: the share of national growth each region is forecast to receive, a detailed assessment of existing dwellings and the development actually in the pipeline, and the reconciliation of those two against each other.

That difference matters most when a forecast goes in front of someone else. A number set in-house is the organisation's own view of its future. An independent assessment carries more weight with a reviewer, because the assumptions were set by someone with no stake in the outcome.

The forecast is also one part of a wider evidence base. Informed Decisions publishes demographic, economic, housing and community data for the same places, so a forecast can be read alongside who lives there now, how the local economy is tracking and how housing is being delivered.

What follows compares the two on method, using each provider's published documentation.

BEFORE YOU COMPARE

What actually decides a population forecast

Forecasts of the same place can differ by tens of thousands of people. Almost all of that difference comes down to three assumptions, and they are worth understanding before comparing any two providers.

Where and when dwellings get built. People live in dwellings, so a small area cannot grow faster than homes appear in it. That makes the dwelling assumption the largest single driver of a local forecast, and it cannot be derived from history alone. It takes knowing which sites are coming, how many dwellings each will yield, when construction starts, how quickly they fill, and what happens when an area runs out of land to build on.

How many people live in each dwelling. Household size converts dwellings into people, and it is not a constant. It differs between a new apartment precinct and an established suburb of family homes, and it shifts as an area ages. Two forecasts with identical dwelling numbers will still disagree if they treat household size differently.

What the total is allowed to be. A forecast built for one area in isolation can say almost anything, because nothing outside it pushes back. A forecast built inside a national and state model cannot: the growth it gives an area has to be growth the country actually has.

Dwelling research is the largest single investment behind the National Forecasting Program, and that page covers how it is done.

A place is forecast as part of the country, not on its own

Growth is not created locally. How many people Australia has in a given year is set by births, deaths and overseas migration. How many any one region has is set by where those people go. The real question a local forecast answers is what share of the country's growth lands in that place.

The National Forecasting Program is built that way round. It forecasts the nation, then the states, then the regions, then each local area's share within them, using one method everywhere in Australia. Every local forecast sits inside the same national picture, and none of them can assume a share of growth the country does not have to give.

That is also what makes a number hold up when someone else checks it. A forecast for a single area, built without that context, is difficult to defend against a state projection that was built with it.

The Informed Decisions knowledge base explains what top-down forecasting is and how the constraint is applied.

At a glance

Informed Decisions: National Forecasting ProgramPlace Info: Place ForecastWhy it matters
How future dwellings are projectedEvery residential project of 10 or more dwellings, more than 50,000 sites across Australia, each researched for capacity, timing and sequence and kept current as ongoing researchThe last 12 months of building approvals held steady, converted to completions using observed construction timelinesApproved does not mean built. With construction capacity one of many factors in project feasibility, each site is assessed for timing, sequence and capacity instead of a blanket assumption
National and state contextEvery local area is forecast as a share of a national and state picture, using one method across AustraliaAnchored to ABS estimates of the current population. No forward national or state projection described in the published materialEach area is forecast to receive the share of national, state and regional demand its demographic patterns point to. That top-down total is what gives the forecast its credibility
How the age profile is producedEvery person aged by single year of age, with births, deaths and moves in and out of each area forecast directlyDwellings described as a major driver. The published equation calculates people leaving an area as the remainder once the population total is setThe forecast follows the people counted at the last Census as they age in place or move along observed migration patterns, so school and aged care planning rests on who actually lives there
Average household sizeForecast to change over time, by dwelling type and by areaCarried forward from the jump-off year unless a council supplies its own assumptionHolding household size flat in an ageing area understates how many dwellings the same population needs
Who supplies local development knowledgeInformed Decisions' development researchers, as part of the productThe council, through add, reduce, override and ceiling adjustmentsDevelopment assumptions are the biggest difference between the two. An independent, comprehensive view of every site is informed by council input and feedback, and never rests on it alone
Who produces the forecastA dedicated forecasting team of demographers and development researchers, each responsible for their own regionsThe user, on top of a mechanical baselineDemographers who know the role and function of each place can tell a meaningful trend from an anomaly in the data
What an update changesThe development pipeline is re-researched site by site and the area reforecast inside the latest national and state pictureThe starting population and recent building approvals refresh as new official data arrives. The forward path still rests on the approvals baselineA change in the forecast reflects a material change in the information likely to shape the outcome, and anomalies in the data are not carried forward
Written analysisPublished with every region release as forecast analysisNot stated publiclyEach change comes with an explanation that can go straight into a council report or briefing
CoverageEvery small area in Australia, in every state, on one method. Any geography a client names can be built and reconciled to the totalsClient councils: the local government area and the small areas within itServices and catchments that cross council or state lines can be planned on one consistent set of numbers
Benchmarking against other placesAny area can be compared with the state or any other area in Australia, on the same method and the same releaseNo national forecast set described in the published material, so places cannot be compared on one methodA council can show how its growth compares with similar places, like for like
Clients using the evidence baseMore than 130 councils, plus retail, infrastructure, emergency services and state government, including Coles, Woolworths, NBN Co, NSW Ambulance, the NSW Department of Education and the Victorian Electoral CommissionSold as a council subscription. No client organisations named in the published materialClients with different interests in the outcome plan from one trusted, independent evidence base

WHAT THE METHOD BUYS YOU

Why organisations choose the National Forecasting Program

An independent assessment. Most of the moments that matter involve someone questioning the number: a state department, a planning panel, a funding body, a developer, a court. A forecast set by the organisation presenting it is open to the charge that it says what that organisation wanted. One produced independently, inside a national model, holds up better when it is questioned.

Research rather than settings. Where and when dwellings get built is the biggest single driver of a local forecast, so it is researched rather than projected from recent approvals. The research covers every residential project of 10 or more dwellings, more than 50,000 sites across Australia, each with its capacity, expected start and expected completion. Sites are identified and tracked as ongoing research, using council data, building approvals, aerial photography, property databases and land-use change, and checked with councils.

A dedicated forecasting team. The forecasts are produced by Informed Decisions' own demographers and development researchers, each responsible for their regions, and each release carries written analysis from the forecaster who produced it. Informed Decisions has worked with more than 300 councils for over 30 years. Principal consultant Johnny Barnard, for example, has forecast Australia's urban change since the late 1980s and has given evidence on population forecasting to the Victorian Parliament.

One method everywhere, so any place can be benchmarked. The same methodology covers every small area in Australia, in every state. A council can set its forecast against the state and against similar places elsewhere, on the same method and the same release, and anyone planning services, networks or investment across more than one area gets numbers that compare.

A published methodology. How the forecast is built is documented and public, so the assumption driving growth in any small area can be produced on request.

More than a forecast. The National Forecasting Program sits within a wider evidence base for the same places: Community Profile for who lives there, Economic Profile for the local economy, Housing Monitor for housing supply and delivery, Social Atlas for where needs are concentrated, and Community Views for what residents say. Planning and investment decisions can draw on all of it from one recognised source.

Scenarios that start from the national picture. Testing what follows from a set of assumptions, such as a rezoning, a new rail line or a development target, is a common need. Place Forecast handles it by letting the user set the assumptions for their own area. Informed Decisions offers scenario modelling built on the National Forecasting Program, so each scenario starts from a forecast already set inside the national and state picture, and the forecasting team helps work through what would need to be true for it to happen.

Questions people ask

The two are different kinds of product, even though they are sometimes bought for similar purposes. Place Info's Place Forecast is a self-serve tool: it supplies a baseline for one area and the user sets the assumptions. Informed Decisions' National Forecasting Program is an independent forecast, produced by a dedicated team of demographers on one consistent method for every part of Australia, and used across industries with quite different interests in the rate of development. In most cases what those organisations want is an honest assessment of the most likely outcome, from a recognised source with no position to argue.

Where the job is to test what follows from a particular level of development, Informed Decisions also offers scenario modelling. Each scenario is built on the same national model, so it still starts from the share of national and state growth that area can realistically expect.

Three questions worth asking.

How to test any forecast

What are the dwellings in this forecast based on, and has anyone looked at the development pipeline in this area? Is the area forecast as a share of a national and state picture, or on its own? And what is assumed about household size over the forecast period?

Those three answers explain most of the difference between any two forecasts of the same place. Informed Decisions publishes its answers to all three, and will walk through them for a specific area on request.